Seoul returns defectors amid calls for renewed inter-Korean dialogue and backlash from activists
South Korean has returned six North Koreans who had drifted into its waters earlier this year, with all expressing a “strong and consistent desire” to return home, according to the Ministry of Unification.
This marks the first repatriation under President Lee Jae-myung, who took office in June and has signaled a shift toward rebuilding diplomatic ties with Pyongyang. The repatriation took place Wednesday morning near the maritime boundary, where North Korean patrol and fishing vessels were seen, suggesting behind-the-scenes coordination despite no formal communication.
“They’ll be grilled on whether they received any espionage training,” said Nam Sung-wook, former head of the Korea National Strategy Institute.
A politically charged return
The six individuals include:
- Two who entered in March, remaining in the South for four months (the longest stay for non-defectors), and
- Four sailors who crossed the disputed maritime border in May.
Due to Pyongyang cutting inter-Korean communications in 2023, coordination had been attempted via the US-led United Nations Command, but no response was received. Despite this, the handover proceeded without incident.
This comes as President Lee Jae-myung has vowed to reduce tensions and resume dialogue with the North. Just days into his presidency, Lee suspended cross-border loudspeaker broadcasts, citing the move as a “trust-building step.”
Human rights concerns and backlash
The decision has sparked concern among North Korean defectors and activists, who argue the six should have been offered asylum or at least exposure to South Korea’s democratic society.
“They should have been allowed to hear the truth about life in the South,” said activist Lee Min-bok.
Some fear the returnees will face interrogation and punishment, despite their voluntary repatriation. Analysts also note that their return serves Pyongyang’s propaganda goals, highlighting supposed loyalty to Kim Jong Un’s regime.
What this means for inter-Korean relations
Experts remain skeptical about a thaw in ties.
“North Korea has built strong ties with Russia and sees little strategic value in engaging the South,” says Celeste Arrington of George Washington University.
Public opinion in South Korea also reflects declining support for engagement, a trend that may hinder Lee’s reunification ambitions.
Meanwhile, a controversial bill banning activist balloon launches carrying anti-Kim leaflets is under debate, raising further concerns about free speech under the new administration.
Seoul returns six North Koreans with ‘strong desire’ to go back
Ukraine suffers heaviest attack as Trump criticises Putin
